Gummies and tablets sit on the same shelf carrying the same nutrient, and the gummy usually costs several times more per dose. This guide sets out what the formats actually differ on, how to read a gummy label, and how to work out price per dose rather than price per pack.
What UK guidance says about supplement format
Nothing. UK guidance names nutrients and amounts, not formats. The NHS says adults aged 19 to 64 "need 40mg of vitamin C a day", and that "Children from the age of 1 year and adults need 10 micrograms (mcg) of vitamin D supplements a day". Neither page mentions gummies or tablets. The Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003 set out which forms may be sold and what the label must carry, and set no disintegration or dissolution test at all.
Authorised claims are the same both ways. Those on the Great Britain Nutrition and Health Claims Register attach to the nutrient and the amount delivered, not to the thing delivering it, so a 500mg vitamin C gummy may say what a 500mg tablet may say.
What actually separates a gummy from a tablet
A tablet is a compressed powder. A gummy is a confection: the nutrient is suspended in a heated gel base, usually pectin or gelatine, alongside sugar or a sugar substitute, acid, flavour and colour. That base is the whole difference.
Scientists at the US Food and Drug Administration's Office of Dietary Supplement Programs set the consequences out in the Journal of Dietary Supplements on 17 September 2026. They name "ensuring the accuracy of the quantitative amount of dietary ingredients claimed on the label" as a challenge specific to the format, and, as an FDA spokesperson put it to NutraIngredients, "certain ingredients can degrade during the matrix heating". It is a perspective paper, not a rule, and no new requirements came with it.
One attempt to measure the problem is a manufacturer's. NOW Foods bought two samples each from 25 vitamin C gummy brands on Amazon in June 2026, picked because it doubted their labelling, and measured ascorbic acid by HPLC in-house and at the ISO 17025 accredited Alkemist Labs. Thirteen met their label claim. Twelve had almost no detectable vitamin C, and the five claiming 1,000mg or more per gummy each contained under 2mg. NOW sells gummies itself, so this is a competitor's testing rather than a regulator's survey, and the five established brands it included for comparison all passed. The gel base introduces a failure mode tablets do not have, and no MHRA or Food Standards Agency survey has measured how common it is here.
Dose per serving, and how to read the label
Regulation 6 of the 2003 Regulations requires the label to give "the portion of the product recommended for daily consumption" and the amount of each nutrient per that portion. The number on the front of a gummy pack is therefore per serving, and a serving is commonly two gummies. That halves the pack. Sixty gummies at two a day is 30 servings, a month rather than two.
Units confuse vitamin D. The NHS pairs 100 micrograms with 4,000 IU, which puts 1,000 IU at 25 micrograms and 400 IU at 10 micrograms. A gummy advertising 1,000 IU a serving delivers 25 micrograms, two and a half times the 10 micrograms the NHS says "will be enough for most people", and a quarter of the adult ceiling of 100 micrograms. That ceiling is 50 micrograms (2,000 IU) for children aged 1 to 10.
The sugar question, and why the pack may not answer it
Article 29(1) of retained Regulation 1169/2011 excludes food supplements from Section 3 of Chapter IV, the nutrition declaration. A gummy sold in Great Britain can therefore print its vitamin content and no sugar figure at all, legally. Where there is none, read the ingredients list, in which sugars appear by name and in descending order of weight.
Where a figure is given it is usually modest. The panel for Nordic Naturals Vitamin C Extra Strength Gummies lists 2g of added sugars per two gummy serving: about a fifteenth of the NHS limit of 30g of free sugars a day for an adult, nearer a tenth for a child aged 4 to 6, where the limit is 19g. Timing matters more than the total. The NHS states that "Sugar is one of the main causes of tooth decay" and advises limiting free sugars to mealtimes, and a gummy chewed mid-morning sits outside that advice.
Sugar-free labels carry a requirement of their own. Annex III of the same regulation requires foods with more than 10% added polyols to carry the words "excessive consumption may produce laxative effects". That requirement sits in Section 1 of the same chapter, from which supplements are not exempt.
How to compare price per dose
Divide the pack price by servings, not units, then scale to a common dose. At our standard prices on 23 October 2026, per 1,000mg of vitamin C:
- Vitamin C-1000 with Rose Hips and Bioflavonoids, 1,000mg per tablet, 100 tablets at £11.99: 12p
- Vitamin C Extra Strength Gummies, 500mg per two gummy serving, 60 gummies at £19.91: 66p a serving, so £1.33
- Vitamin C Gummies, 250mg per two gummy serving, 120 gummies at £23.49: 39p a serving, so £1.57
Eleven to thirteen times the tablet, for the same nutrient. Vitamin D narrows the gap. Gummies at 1,000 IU a serving, £22.99 for 120, come to 38p a serving against 15p for 1,000 IU softgels at £18.49 for 120, though that comparator is a softgel rather than a tablet. The premium buys palatability, worth paying when the alternative is a supplement nobody takes.
Cautions worth naming
Combined intake is the practical one. A multivitamin gummy and a single nutrient gummy together can push vitamin D past the ceilings above, and the taste makes a second helping easier than with a tablet. Add up what every product in the cupboard contributes.
Some vitamin D gummies also contain vitamin K. The NHS warfarin page says: "Do not take the herbal remedy St John's wort or vitamin K supplements while you're taking warfarin."
Keep them out of reach of young children. Regulation 6 requires every label to say so, and on something that tastes like sweets that is not boilerplate.
What we stock
Gummies and tablets from established brands sit together in our vitamins and minerals range, with the dose per serving on each listing so the comparison above is possible. Everything is sourced through PowerBody, an authorised EU distributor. Membership costs £4.99 a month or £29.99 a year and unlocks member pricing: see the membership page.
Related reading
- Vitamin D3 and K2: how to choose, and what the evidence actually shows
- Zinc supplements in the UK: picolinate vs gluconate vs citrate
This article is for information only. Food supplements are not a substitute for a varied diet or medical care, and no product mentioned is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Speak to your GP or pharmacist before changing what you take, especially if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, giving supplements to a child, or taking prescribed medicines such as warfarin.
Sources
- NHS: Vitamin C
- NHS: Vitamin D
- NHS: Vitamin K
- NHS: How much sugar is good for me?
- NHS: Warfarin
- The Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003, regulation 6: restrictions on sale relating to labelling
- The Food Supplements (England) Regulations 2003, table of contents
- Retained Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Article 29: exemption of food supplements from the nutrition declaration
- Retained Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Annex III: foods whose labelling must include additional particulars, including polyols and sweeteners
- Great Britain nutrition and health claims (NHC) register, DHSC
- Hu H, Redan B, Celiz MD, Pawar R, Yakes BJ. Perspective on Gummy Dietary Supplements Manufacturing and Testing. Journal of Dietary Supplements, 17 September 2026
- Sticky situation: FDA weighs in on gummy dietary supplements, NutraIngredients, 7 October 2026
- NOW's testing of vitamin C gummies on Amazon returns 'deeply disappointing results', NutraIngredients, 20 August 2026
- NOW Foods: NOW tests vitamin C gummy supplements sold on Amazon
- Nordic Naturals Vitamin C Extra Strength Gummies, supplement facts panel
- Perqen: Vitamin C-1000 with Rose Hips & Bioflavonoids, 100 tablets (price checked 23 October 2026)
- Perqen: Vitamin C Extra Strength Gummies, Tangerine, 60 gummies (price checked 23 October 2026)
- Perqen: Vitamin D3 Gummies, 1000 IU Wild Berry, 120 gummies (price checked 23 October 2026)
- Retained Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, table of contents (Article 29 sits in Chapter IV Section 3, the nutrition declaration; Article 10 in Section 1)