Two of the systems the UK uses to decide which food and drink counts as unhealthy flag far fewer products than models built directly on government dietary guidance, according to a cross sectional analysis published in BMJ Medicine on 10 November 2026. Researchers at University College London and the University of Cambridge assessed 1,898 items from year 12 of the National Diet and Nutrition Survey database, covering 2019-20, made up of 262 processed products and 1,636 ultraprocessed ones classified by the Nova system used by the World Health Organization. Each item was run through the Food Standards Agency nutrient profiling model, through front-of-pack traffic light labelling, and through three new models the team built from UK dietary recommendations in the Eatwell Guide covering saturated fat, free sugar, sodium, total fat and energy density. The paper analyses the composition of products on sale; it measured nobody's diet and no health outcome.
What the analysis found
The FSA model identified 57.6% of ultraprocessed products as unhealthy, with a 95% confidence interval of 55.2% to 60.0%, and the traffic light system identified 48.2%, the paper reports. The first of the three new models identified 91.5% of the same products as unhealthy, the second 94.9% and the third 98.7%, differences the authors describe as statistically significant. They also note that whole categories typically high in saturated fat, salt or sugar, including savoury pastries and chocolate spreads, are exempt from the FSA model. FoodNavigator reports that a 2018 revision of that model, due to be implemented in January 2027, still identified 25% to 35% fewer processed and ultraprocessed products as unhealthy than the most conservative of the three. Funders recorded for the paper include the National Institute for Health and Care Research, the Medical Research Council, Rosetrees Trust and the Pan American Health Organization.
What this means in practice
Two limitations sit over the figures. New Food reports that the analysis excluded minimally processed products, and that it treated every eligible item as carrying a traffic light label when that scheme is voluntary and not all eligible products display one. The nutrient data also dates from 2019-20. A product that no current system flags has not been shown to sit inside UK recommendations for fat, sugar and salt; it has only fallen the right side of the threshold one model uses. The authors make the case for a single system with agreed thresholds aligned to dietary guidance, and a linked editorial by Shashika Rathnayaka and Franco Sassi of Imperial College London argues that classifying products better is only part of improving diets. Nothing in the paper concerns a food supplement, and questions about your own diet stay with a GP or a registered dietitian.
How Perqen members save
This is a food policy and labelling story rather than one about anything Perqen stocks, so there is no product link here. Membership costs £4.99 a month or £29.99 a year and unlocks member pricing across the full Perqen catalogue, on the terms set out on the Perqen membership page.
This article reports published news and research and is for information only. Food supplements are not a substitute for a varied diet or medical care, and no product mentioned is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Speak to your GP or pharmacist before changing what you take, especially if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or taking prescribed medicines.
Sources
- Dicken SJ, van Tulleken DRZ, Brown A, Gomes FS, van Tulleken C. Evaluation of energy density and levels of fat, sugar, and salt in processed and ultra-processed food with existing and novel nutrient profiling models to identify unhealthy food and drink: cross sectional analysis of a nationally representative database of food and drink items. BMJ Medicine 2026;5:e001750. Published online 10 November 2026
- Rathnayaka S, Sassi F. Defining unhealthy food in the era of ultraprocessing. BMJ Medicine, published online 10 November 2026 (linked editorial)
- UK food classification systems missing thousands of unhealthy products (New Food, 12 November 2026)
- UK nutrient profiling models miss half of unhealthy ultra-processed foods (FoodNavigator, 12 November 2026)