Which? has reported that five widely sold vitamin D supplements self-test kits returned three different verdicts when run on the same person on the same day. The investigation was published on 30 October 2026 by Sara Spary, a senior researcher and writer at Which?, and covered finger-prick rapid tests from Boots, Berkeley Health, MyHealthChecked, OneStep and Newfoundland, sold through high street shops, Amazon and major supermarkets. Each was used following its instructions, with a different finger, and set against a private venous blood test taken the same day at a Care Quality Commission registered provider. That venous test placed the tester well within the sufficient range. Newfoundland and Berkeley Health returned deficient, MyHealthChecked and OneStep returned insufficient, and the Boots own-brand kit returned sufficient. All five stated the same accuracy figure of 94.4%, taken from an in-house study of 90 blood samples, four of which the patient leaflets describe as vitamin D deficient.
Two thresholds, and one maker behind four of the kits
The NHS and most private laboratories treat a reading above 50nmol/L as sufficient, Which? reports, while the rapid tests use a higher cut-off of 75nmol/L, so the same blood can fall on either side of the line. Which? reports that the Boots, MyHealthChecked, OneStep and Newfoundland tests were said to be made by the same company, and that the Boots and MyHealthChecked kits appeared to be the same product by reference, manufacturer and performance data, yet disagreed with each other. Boots, which also owns MyHealthChecked, said both were compliant with the relevant regulations and that self-test kits were intended as a screening option rather than a laboratory test. Berkeley Health said its clinical evidence was “entirely sufficient”. OneStep did not respond. Which? is not the first to raise this. University of Birmingham researchers reported in The BMJ in July 2025 on 30 UK self-tests priced from £1.89 to £39.99, finding fewer than half of the boxes said anything about accuracy.
What this means in practice
Sue Davies, head of consumer rights and food policy at Which?, said: “It is deeply concerning that tests sold by major high street brands and online gave completely contradictory results,” adding that “an inaccurate result risks driving people to spend money on potentially harmful high-dose supplements, or leaving a genuine deficiency untreated.” Dr Bernie Croal, president of the Royal College of Pathologists, said he was not surprised by the findings and that “vitamin D testing can lead to harm. If people go on vitamin D tablets and the dose is too high, that can lead to high calcium levels in the blood with an increased risk of kidney stones.” Rob Reid, MHRA Deputy Director of Innovative Devices, said consumers “should seek advice from an appropriately qualified healthcare professional to ensure that test results are interpreted in the correct clinical context”. Which? says the MHRA told it it would assess the evidence and is reviewing the existing rules. Perqen sells no self-test kits; our FAQs cover how member pricing works.
How Perqen members save
Perqen membership costs £4.99 a month or £29.99 a year, and member pricing then applies across the catalogue instead of a markup on each product. The Perqen membership pricing page sets out how the two options compare.
This article reports published news and research and is for information only. Food supplements are not a substitute for a varied diet or medical care, and no product mentioned is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Speak to your GP or pharmacist before changing what you take, especially if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or taking prescribed medicines.